The Guilty Party: Metiria is guilty of a crime – but not the one John Armstrong rails against in his latest column. Her transgression was to break ranks with the socio-political formation that has kept Richardson’s and Shipley’s welfare cuts bleeding and raw for more than quarter-of-a-century.
Lacking the imagination for empathy, Armstrong and his ilk
cling for comfort to the rules, all the rules, and nothing but the rules.
“She endeavoured to turn her breach of the law into a
launching pad for her party’s welfare policy. That is audacious. It is also the
height of arrogance. It is also to enter very dangerous territory. It implies
you are above the law. It says it is okay to break the law in order to try and
change it.”
Yes, John, that’s exactly what it implies. But, tell me, do
you think that Mahatma Ghandi, Dr Martin Luther King or Nelson Mandela would
have any ethical difficulty dealing with those implications?
Metiria was required to raise her daughter in the years immediately
following the Mother of All Budgets. You must remember that extraordinary act
of social violence, John? When Ruth Richardson, with enthusiastic support from
Jenny Shipley, slashed the already meagre incomes of New Zealand’s most
vulnerable citizens by 25 percent? When the National Government of Jim Bolger
did exactly what Metiria told her party a Green government would never do: Use
poverty as a weapon against its own people?
Do you really expect us to believe, John, that you would
have accepted the National Government’s vicious policies without protest or
subterfuge – and watched your child go hungry? If that really is your position,
then why did you write: “There is sympathy for her past plight and respect for
her efforts in pulling herself out of it.”
Clearly, you understand that falling into the clutches of
Work & Income was, and is, a predicament – a “plight” – and that getting
out of it isn’t easy. It requires a working knowledge of every trick in the
book. Some of those tricks are legal. Others are not. But, for their children,
people do what they have to do. If you would rather they didn’t “steal” from
the Government, John, then why not insist that the Government gives them enough
to live on?
But you don’t want to do that, do you, John? No, you would
rather use the poor against the poor. Like when you write: “Turei’s flouting of
the law will further alienate low-income families in which both parents work
long hours and who consequently cannot abide welfare cheats. Those voters are
already deserting the centre-left. Turei’s holier-than-thou disposition is
hardly going to attract them back.”
And how would you know what low-income families are
thinking, John? Has it never occurred to you that those “welfare cheats” (what
an odious gob of verbal spittle that is!) are the sons and daughters of the
working poor? How many of them, do you suppose, have attempted to support their
children at the local Work & Income office and experienced first-hand the
icy condescension and bureaucratic cruelty of MSD employees?
No, John, you don’t anything about that world of hurt and
anger. What you do know, however, is what they should be thinking
- and you will not hesitate to tell them at every given opportunity. Because the
Right is terrified – yes, terrified – that Metiria’s admission that she was
willing to lie to keep food on her little family’s table might persuade a
dangerously large number of those low-income families that at least some Green
MPs know what their own children are going through. And that the prospect of
MSD’s hated “sanctions” being abolished might even convince those families
that, this time, it’s worth casting a vote.
Metiria is guilty of a crime – but not the one John
Armstrong rails against. Her transgression was to break ranks with the
socio-political formation that has kept Richardson’s and Shipley’s welfare cuts
bleeding and raw for more than quarter-of-a-century.
When Metiria Turei told the Green AGM that: “We will not be
a government that uses poverty as a weapon against its own people”, she must have known that she was breaking the
biggest rule of all.
And that the John Armstrongs of this world would never
forgive her.
This essay was
originally posted on The Daily Blog
of Saturday, 22 July 2017.



