Going Down? Once truth and propaganda become fused in the minds of one’s followers, debate and discussion become redundant. If one’s opponents are all outrageous liars, then engaging with them in any way is pointless. Rather than waste its time, a political party should, instead, target all its messages at those who have yet to grasp the full mendacity of the other side. Tell these “persuadables” the truth – your truth – before the other parties tell them theirs.
AND SO IT BEGINS, the National Party’s simultaneous descent
and ascent. Downwards, into the dark territory of “whatever it takes”. Upwards,
into the glare of electoral victory. It’s happening because the party’s present
leader has convinced himself that it is only the first movement which makes
possible the second.
Simon Bridges will, however, discover that conducting this
double movement exacts a heavy toll. The National Party prime ministers we
remember fondly: Sir Keith Holyoake, Jim Bolger, Sir John Key; all got to the
top by taking a different route. National’s prime-ministerial villains: Sid
Holland and Rob Muldoon; both chose the low road to power.
By the time Bridges gets to switch on the lights on the
Beehive’s ninth floor, “whatever it takes” will have wrought its inevitable
changes. The face that stares at him from the mirror of the prime-ministerial
bathroom will be as unfamiliar as it is frightening.
Bridges’ journey into the heart of darkness began in
Australia. His induction to the black political arts that secured the
Australian Liberal leader, Scott Morrison’s, surprise election victory, is
evident in the stinging social media campaign the National Opposition launched
soon after his return.
The campaign’s effectiveness, like the Brexit, Trump and
Morrison precedents from which it borrows so heavily, has nothing to do with
the presentation of positive policy. It does not seek to inform but to inflame.
It bypasses both the heart and the head and goes straight for the gut. It
arouses not hope but hate. Its goal is not unity but division. And it’s
working.
Emboldened by this success, Bridges has descended the next
few steps of the dark staircase at a canter. Rather than seize upon the
opportunity provided by the stand-off at Ihumatao to advance the Treaty
relationship – as Jim Bolger and Doug Graham took advantage of the Maori
Renaissance in the early 1990s – Bridges has taken his inspiration from Don
Brash.
In the face of the protesters resistance, Prime Minister Jacinda
Ardern has been advised to “send them home”. Bridges knows that dismantling the
Ihumatao campsite and moving its inhabitants on will be achieved only by the
application of force majeure: concerted and forceful police and/or
military action. He also knows that the use of state violence at Ihumatao will
necessitate its further and escalating use in the large-scale protest action
that is bound to follow. He does not care. Why should he, when his political
objective is to keep the electorate divided, angry and on-edge?
As if Bridges’ turning away from a brokered solution at
Ihumatao isn’t bad enough, he has taken advantage of the serious failings at
Statistics New Zealand to descend even further down the dark staircase.
On this morning’s (14/8/19) Morning Report, Bridges
deliberately sowed seeds of doubt about the reliability of whole swathes of
state-provided data. How could we trust electoral boundaries drawn up on the
basis of statistical information that may be false? How can we have any faith
in the economic and fiscal reports released by the Government?
This is an especially dangerous game to play. From calling
into question the reliability of official information it is but a short step to
advancing the Trumpian claim that the public is being assailed by “fake news”,
or, worse still, that the election is being rigged.
This is no small matter. Once truth and propaganda become
fused in the minds of one’s followers, debate and discussion become redundant.
If one’s opponents are all outrageous liars, then engaging with them in any way
is pointless. Rather than waste its time, a political party should, instead,
target all its messages at those who have yet to grasp the full mendacity of
the other side. Tell these “persuadables” the truth – your truth – before the
other parties tell them theirs.
A key factor in any National victory arrived at via
the low road is shaping up to be the Sustainable NZ Party. The party’s founder,
Vernon Tava, may be perfectly sincere in his quest for a less polarising
expression of ecological wisdom – as may the 500-plus people he has already
signed-up to secure his new party’s official registration. Sadly, the
genuineness or otherwise of Tava and his moderate environmentalists is
irrelevant to Bridges and his fellow-travellers in the dark.
All that Bridges and his strategists are hoping for is that
Sustainable NZ will lure away just enough support from the Greens to cause them
to fall below the 5 percent MMP threshold. All it will take is for a few
thousand Green voters – many of them, perhaps, alarmed by some of the claims
being made about Green Party MPs on social media – to defect to the Sustainable
NZ Party, and Labour could find itself with insufficient parliamentary backing
to continue in government. That neither the Greens, nor Sustainable NZ, will be
in Parliament to fight for the environment is likely to be regarded by Bridges
and his team as one of the more satisfying outcomes of the strategy.
A government elected as a result of such egregious bad faith
is unlikely to be one of sweetness and light. If to bad faith we are required
to add conscious lying, fake news, and the deliberate incitement of anger and
division, then that government can only end up being bitter and dark.
“Whatever it takes” is really just another way of saying
“the end justifies the means”. But, if history has taught us anything it is
that the means we use, determine the ends we achieve. Bring National to power
by dark methods, Simon Bridges, and you will soon find yourself and your
government unable to accomplish anything but dark deeds.
This essay was originally posted on The Daily Blog
of Thursday, 15 August 2019.
